Which of these two looks do you prefer on a girl?

Which of these two looks do you prefer on a girl?
1) An attractive and lady-like female
who wears mostly designer clothes.
As in: knee-length skirts, 1950s type dresses, blouses and ballerina shoes.
High-maintainance, well brought up, and loves gossip.
She's outgoing, talkative, likes to party,
and ISN'T stuck up or boring,
at least towards those she approves of.
Little eye make up and bright red lipstick.
Fair-skinned, long dark hair,
average height and hourglass figure (ie: nice boobs, no butt).

2) An attractive female with a biker girl look.
Not aggressive in style, but not delicate either.
As in: skinny jeans, boots, and a leather jacket.
Prefers dark colors and chooses quality over quantity.
Upper class and well brought up.
Hates gossip, is shy / reserved, and might seem aloof.
Wears eye make up and black eyeliner, natural lips / face.
Fair-skinned, medium dark hair,
5' 8'' and slim (ie: no boobs, nice butt)

Which one would you "pick" as a girlfriend / partner?
What makes you prefer one over the other?